My apologies everyone!! I have a mistake in the cutting directions for the LeMoyne Star.
From the light print:
Cut (4) 1 1/2" x 2 1/2" rectangles.....
not 1 1/2" x 3 1/2".
Also, trim your Half Square Triangles to 1 1/2"
So, so sorry about this!! At least your pieces are bigger than need be and you can cut them down to the proper size.
My bad!! I feel terrible....ugh!
The corrections are in my original blog post in red.
Katie O...thanks for your comment alerting me to the problem. I think it's my brain that's fried!